70万元假画案画家作证表示仅值三五百元收购名人字画联系方式保护珍贵物品

  • 艺术市场
  • 2025年05月19日
  • 近日,李某花70万元从张某处购得一幅署名史国良的画作《金秋》,后经史国良本人鉴定为仿制品。李某多次与卖主张某协商退款未果,故诉至法院,要求返还购画款并承担相应利息。原告李某诉称,他在任某介绍下认识了张某,并于2014年7月3日在北京购买了这幅画。在购买前,他详细询问了画的来源,但张 Certain assured him that the painting came directly from

70万元假画案画家作证表示仅值三五百元收购名人字画联系方式保护珍贵物品

近日,李某花70万元从张某处购得一幅署名史国良的画作《金秋》,后经史国良本人鉴定为仿制品。李某多次与卖主张某协商退款未果,故诉至法院,要求返还购画款并承担相应利息。原告李某诉称,他在任某介绍下认识了张某,并于2014年7月3日在北京购买了这幅画。在购买前,他详细询问了画的来源,但张 Certain assured him that the painting came directly from the artist, "absolutely reliable and genuine." Despite Li's repeated requests for a refund after discovering that the painting was fake, Zhang refused to comply. In February 2023, Li finally obtained a written appraisal from History himself, which concluded that the painting was a forgery. The court ultimately ruled in favor of Li, ordering Zhang to return the purchase price of 70 million yuan plus interest totaling 81.86 million yuan.

During the trial, Zhang's attorney argued that Li had knowingly purchased a potentially fake painting and should not be entitled to a refund. They pointed out that Li had been warned by Zhang to examine the painting before agreeing on a price and that he had sufficient expertise as a dealer in antiques and artworks to recognize any potential issues with authenticity.

Li countered by presenting evidence of his own losses due to buying what he believed were genuine works only later discovered to be fakes. He also produced an expert witness statement from History himself confirming that he recognized one of his paintings being sold at market prices between RMB3000-5000 (USD $400-700).

The judge ultimately found in favor of Li based on History's testimony confirming his suspicions about the counterfeit nature of both paintings sold by defendant Zhang.

In this case, we can see how important it is for buyers or collectors who are interested in purchasing valuable items such as art pieces or rare artifacts have access accurate information about their provenance history so they can make informed decisions when making purchases online or offline through local galleries etc., especially when dealing with unscrupulous sellers trying take advantage them financially while selling them imitations instead authentic masterpieces created by renowned artists like painter history who is known worldwide for creating stunning portraits capturing emotions beauty human form

猜你喜欢